Connection Before Content: How to Respond When Employees Open Up

Posted on November 12, 2026 by Nate Regier / 0 comments
Share via

A bid for connection is any moment someone shares something real: a feeling, a worry, a dilemma, or an idea. The best leadership response is to validate their experience, then ask a curious question, before offering any solutions.

What is a bid for connection at work?

When someone opens up to you about what they are experiencing inside, it’s a rare leadership moment and a bid for connection that can build deeper trust and engagement. It might show itself in the most subtle moments:

  • Sharing a feeling that might be raw, difficult, or new. For example, “I’ve been struggling with knowing how to give feedback to my employees who used to be my peers before I was promoted.”
  • Describing a perspective they haven’t shared with anyone before.  “I’ve been worried that AI is negatively affecting my team’s critical thinking skills.”
  • Expressing ambivalence about a decision. “I am torn about whether to wait until after the holiday to break the news of my new role.”
  • Testing an idea. “I was wondering, what if we invited people to help design the rollout instead of just announcing it to them?”

What’s your first response when someone opens up to you? Unfortunately, too many well-meaning leaders (and coaches, parents, therapists, teachers, friends, coworkers) squander this opportunity. Not for lack of good intentions, but because they are too eager to solve problems instead of building connection. This missed opportunity costs trust, engagement, innovation, and resilience during change.

Four ways leaders miss bids for connection

Here are some of the ways well-meaning leaders miss the opportunity when someone opens up to them:

Offer advice

Sensing a problem, you offer input, even though it wasn’t asked for, and even though you don’t fully understand the problem yet. This sends the message that you don’t care about what the person is really experiencing and see their struggle as another problem you can solve.

Make it about you

You can relate to their situation, and it reminds you of a similar experience you had. So you launch into your own story, making it all about you. When employees ask for more empathy from their leaders, this is NOT what they mean. There’s a fine line between empathy and one-upping.

Sidestep the emotion

There’s emotion in the air, and you are uncomfortable, so you avoid it by changing the subject or steering the conversation towards something more comfortable for you. This sends the message that you can’t handle the feels, and can’t help your employee understand and regulate their own emotions. Incidentally, emotional awareness and regulation is one of the most critical survival skills during rapid change and disruption.

Redefine their experience

This is the most damaging response of all. You might respond with fake assurance: “Hey, it’s no big deal. You’ll figure it out,” or suggest they are wrong with comments like, “You’re making a big deal out of nothing.” These kinds of comments send the message that another person’s feelings aren’t real or legitimate. Repeatedly redefining someone else’s experience can feel like gaslighting.

Connection before content: Peter Block’s principle

Peter Block, author of Flawless Consulting and Community: The Structure of Belonging, and a long-standing voice for accountability and belonging at work, puts it simply: 

“We must establish a personal connection with each other. Connection before content. Without relatedness, no work can occur.”

Block asserts that for organizations to thrive, human relationships must come before tasks, agendas, or instructional content. When someone opens up to you, it’s a bid for connection. Before content. Jumping to content before connection first misses a great opportunity.

This doesn’t mean that tasks, agendas, or instructional content aren’t important. It means that without connection, these other things won’t go as well. With connection, there’s a foundation of trust and engagement that makes everything else work better. This is why our Compassionate Accountability conversation template starts with Openness (connection), then Resourcefulness (content and problem-solving), then Persistence (accountabilities), and ends with Openness (connection).

How to respond when an employee opens up: 2 steps

Every human being wants to be seen, heard, and valued. Here is a simple two-step process so you can engage bids for connection before moving on to content.

1. Validate emotions and experiences

As the saying often attributed to Maya Angelou goes, after interactions with us, people will remember how they felt long after they forget what we say or do. Words fade, actions blur, but emotions endure. Missing the leadership moment when people open up can leave a permanent imprint on their heart and mind, and quietly erode trust, engagement, and performance.

Validating a person’s emotions and experiences is as simple as acknowledging what you heard and affirming that their experience matters to them, regardless of whether you can relate or understand. It’s not about you.

2. Get curious with a follow-up question (or two, or three)

When people make a bid for connection, they rarely disclose the full story. They will usually share a little, testing the waters to see how you respond. So the best next thing to do is ask a question to find out more. Get curious and let yourself wonder what’s on the other side of their comment. Delay your own agenda long enough to learn more about their situation. Not only will you show them you care, but you’ll be better equipped to help.

This is what it sounds like. In order, here are responses to the bids for connection above, starting with a validating statement, followed by a curious question.

Bid: “I’ve been struggling with knowing how to give feedback to my employees who used to be my peers before I was promoted.”

Response: “That sounds tough, and a common experience for newly promoted leaders. These can be really tricky situations, and I appreciate you sharing that with me. What’s the hardest part for you?”

Bid: “I’ve been worried that AI is negatively affecting my team’s critical thinking skills.”

Response: “That’s a sobering thought for a leader who wants to empower their people. What are you noticing?”

Bid: “I am torn about whether to wait until after the holiday to break the news of my new role.”

Response: “I hear you. That would be hard. Will you share more about your dilemma?”

Bid: “I was wondering, what if we invited people to help design the rollout instead of just announcing it to them?”

Response: “Interesting idea. I’d love to hear more.”

Case study: from command-and-control to connection

We provide 360 evaluations and coaching for senior leaders who are struggling in their roles. The most common challenge is upgrading their leadership approach to match the increasing pace of change and what the newer generation wants. This two-step process has been a powerful new strategy for these leaders.

One seasoned senior leader, with 15 years of experience and tons of industry knowledge, was struggling to keep up. Several employees filed complaints about his “command and control” approach, and he was feeling burned out from the increasing pressure to perform. His organization was making a concerted effort to upgrade their culture to be more people-focused to attract and retain young talent. His leadership style was increasingly out of sync with the new direction, even though his technical skills and industry knowledge were top-notch. The 360-degree evaluation revealed a big gap between employees’ sense of psychological safety around him and his own perception of his leadership capabilities. What we discovered is that he frequently missed or dismissed bids for connection, so his people stopped opening up.

In our coaching sessions, we practiced the two-step approach for responding to bids for connection. I gave this leader an assignment to notice opportunities and try this new approach. It felt awkward at first, but within a few weeks, this leader was already seeing results. Employees seemed more cooperative and engaged; they disclosed what was really going on, and they asked for help. Over time, he noticed that more people were seeking him out to share their struggles and ask for guidance. At a recent coaching session, this leader shared with me, “I used to think I was supposed to have all the answers and fix everything. Now, I see that my employees are much more capable than I realized. I can say I have an open-door policy, but if I don’t walk the talk, it backfires. The proof is in how I respond when they open up. When I validate their experience and ask curious questions, they know I mean what I say.”

The follow-up 360 evaluation showed measurable improvement in a broad range of behaviors, particularly those most closely related to psychological safety and employee sense of agency.

Why connection matters when leading change

When change accelerates, and the pressure is on, it’s easy to get caught up focusing on content first. Agenda, strategy, efficiency, productivity, results! Let’s go! That might work with your AI agent, but the humans who are managing it all can’t maintain that pace. Humans need connection so they feel safe to be honest, learn from failure, ask for help, trust each other, discern priorities, and regroup when things don’t go as expected. Leaders who practice a connection-before-content approach build teams that are more resilient, nimble, and innovative.

Copyright Next Element Consulting, LLC 2026

Get Certified to Teach Your Leaders How to Connect First


Book Your Next Keynote Speaker

Dr. Nate Regier

Author and Co-founder of Next Element, Dr. Nate Regier is available to speak at your upcoming event.

Submit a Speaker Request

Podcast: Listen to Nate "On Compassion"

On Compassion with Dr. Nate Listen to the Podcast

Join Our Community

Want To Republish Our Posts?

0 Comments

Add comment

Your comment will be revised by the site if needed.